Friday, August 19, 2011
Tuesday, August 16, 2011
Summer Reading Recommendations
I don't know what it is, but I just can't read fiction anymore. My brain rewired itself or something, I dunno, but I'm just not that interested in it anymore. I tried reading through Game of Thrones again, but I only got about halfway through it before putting it down. These are what I've been reading. You should read them too.
This book is very biased, and Zinn writes a disclaimer admitting it. His goal with this book was to tell the story of the oppressed, rather than from the sugarcoated perspective we normally see in history. I would not recommend you start this if you don't already know a thing or two about American history already, so that you can fairly weigh his arguments and disagree with them if you want. For example, I felt that his treatment of the founders was a little unfair. He criticizes them for forming a republic that mostly benefited the elite (true), rather than focusing a social democracy. While certainly valid, I felt that it was a little unfair since Marx and Engels wouldn't write the manifesto until a century later, and they were never exposed to those ideas.
I'm still not through with it yet. It's pretty massive. But that's the great thing about most nonfiction. You can put it down and pick it back up over the course of a few months, like with I've been doing. I'm in the late 1800s/early 1900s right now, and he's going over all the union struggles, and the government's collaboration with business to stamp them out. I'm learning a shit ton of great new info that all my other history books completely breezed over. This book is pretty essential if you want a full picture.
Zinn has a companion book called Voices of a People's History of the United States, which I haven't picked up yet. It's a collection of essays, letters, speeches, and other forms of written word, directly out of the mouths of the people who lived in the eras. I can't wait. Here's an excellent excerpt I found on youtube. This is Josh Brolin reading a statement from pre-Civil War hero John Brown at his court hearing, who led armed insurrection at Harper's Ferry in the hopes of sparking a slave revolution.
And here's Sandra Oh reading Yuri Kochiyama, a Japanese American who was put into a concentration camp during World War II. I couldn't decide which video I liked better, so yeah here's both. Can you understand why I can't fucking wait to get to this? I mean Christ, this almost made me tear up.
--
You can skip over the history stuff if you're not into it, but Empire of Illusion is an absolutely must-read. Hedges describes in excruciating detail just how braindead our society is, and attempts to explain how we got here. This is very grim. He makes a convincing argument that everything is basically hopeless, and all it will take for fascism to arise in the United States is one more 9/11-type disaster, and a demagogue to take advantage of it. He sees little hope, and is convinced that if drastic action is not taken immediately to counteract this illiterate, delusional society, we'll just slip further and further, and soon go the way of Weimar.
--
I feel that it's a little unsafe to base your entire worldview on only one person, but I really can't help it in this case. In high school it was Gandhi, and now I guess it's becoming Noam Chomsky. Reading this book has shifted the lens through which I view the world. You can't say that very many times throughout your life. This is what changed me from being disappointed with Obama and the Democratic party, to advocating tearing down the entire bullshit corrupt corporatist system, and starting anew. This is what convinced me that socialism is a good idea. Understanding Power is a collection of lectures Chomsky has given over the decades, and given that all of his opinions are in one compact place, this seems like the best place to start with him. Can't recommend it enough.
This book is very biased, and Zinn writes a disclaimer admitting it. His goal with this book was to tell the story of the oppressed, rather than from the sugarcoated perspective we normally see in history. I would not recommend you start this if you don't already know a thing or two about American history already, so that you can fairly weigh his arguments and disagree with them if you want. For example, I felt that his treatment of the founders was a little unfair. He criticizes them for forming a republic that mostly benefited the elite (true), rather than focusing a social democracy. While certainly valid, I felt that it was a little unfair since Marx and Engels wouldn't write the manifesto until a century later, and they were never exposed to those ideas.
I'm still not through with it yet. It's pretty massive. But that's the great thing about most nonfiction. You can put it down and pick it back up over the course of a few months, like with I've been doing. I'm in the late 1800s/early 1900s right now, and he's going over all the union struggles, and the government's collaboration with business to stamp them out. I'm learning a shit ton of great new info that all my other history books completely breezed over. This book is pretty essential if you want a full picture.
Zinn has a companion book called Voices of a People's History of the United States, which I haven't picked up yet. It's a collection of essays, letters, speeches, and other forms of written word, directly out of the mouths of the people who lived in the eras. I can't wait. Here's an excellent excerpt I found on youtube. This is Josh Brolin reading a statement from pre-Civil War hero John Brown at his court hearing, who led armed insurrection at Harper's Ferry in the hopes of sparking a slave revolution.
And here's Sandra Oh reading Yuri Kochiyama, a Japanese American who was put into a concentration camp during World War II. I couldn't decide which video I liked better, so yeah here's both. Can you understand why I can't fucking wait to get to this? I mean Christ, this almost made me tear up.
You can skip over the history stuff if you're not into it, but Empire of Illusion is an absolutely must-read. Hedges describes in excruciating detail just how braindead our society is, and attempts to explain how we got here. This is very grim. He makes a convincing argument that everything is basically hopeless, and all it will take for fascism to arise in the United States is one more 9/11-type disaster, and a demagogue to take advantage of it. He sees little hope, and is convinced that if drastic action is not taken immediately to counteract this illiterate, delusional society, we'll just slip further and further, and soon go the way of Weimar.
I feel that it's a little unsafe to base your entire worldview on only one person, but I really can't help it in this case. In high school it was Gandhi, and now I guess it's becoming Noam Chomsky. Reading this book has shifted the lens through which I view the world. You can't say that very many times throughout your life. This is what changed me from being disappointed with Obama and the Democratic party, to advocating tearing down the entire bullshit corrupt corporatist system, and starting anew. This is what convinced me that socialism is a good idea. Understanding Power is a collection of lectures Chomsky has given over the decades, and given that all of his opinions are in one compact place, this seems like the best place to start with him. Can't recommend it enough.
Sunday, August 14, 2011
Saturday, August 6, 2011
Noam Chomsky on whether human nature is inherently corrupt, and on moral values
MAN: Noam, another view I frequently encounter lying behind people's reticence to become involved in political activity stems from the idea that human nature is corrupt: egotistical, self-centered, anti-social, and so on--and that as a result, society will always have oppressors and oppressed, be hierarchical, exploit people, be driven by individual self-interest, etc. I often find that you can get agreement on the inhumanity of the system, or on the injustice of a war, or on some specific set of policies, but that people will refrain from becoming active about it because of a sense of hopelessness having to do with this view of human nature. Again, it may just be an excuse, a last line of defense against getting involved--but in order to deal with it as an organizer, you still have to address the claim. I'm curious what you would say to someone like that.
Well, there's a sense in which the claim is certainly true. First of all, human nature is something we don't know much about: doubtless there is a rich and complex human nature, and doubtless it's largely genetically determined, like everything else--but we don't know what it is. However, there is enough evidence from history and experience to demonstrate that human nature is entirely consistent with everything you mentioned--in fact, by definition it has to be. So we know that human nature, and that includes our nature, yours and mine, can very easily turn people into quite efficient torturers and mass-murderers and slave-drivers. We know that--you don't have to look very far for evidence. But what does that mean? Should people therefore not try to stop torture? If you see somebody beating a child to death, should you say, "Well, you know, that's human nature"--which it is in fact: there certainly are conditions under which people will act like that.
To the extent that the statement is true, and there is such an extent, it's just not relevant: human nature also has the capacity to lead to selflessness, and cooperation, and sacrifice, and support, and solidarity, and tremendous courage, and lots of other things too.
I mean, my general feeling is that over time, there's measurable progress--it's not huge, but it's significant. And sometimes it's been pretty dramatic. Over history, there's been a real widening of the moral realm, I think--a recognition of broader and broader domains of individuals who are regarded as moral agents, meaning having rights. Look, we are self-conscious beings, we're not rocks, and we can come to get a better understanding of our own nature, it can become more and more realized over time--not because you read a book about it, the book doesn't have anything to tell you, because nobody really knows anything about this topic. But just through experience--including historical experience, which is part of our personal experience because it's embedded in the culture we enter into--we can gain greater understanding of our nature and values.
Take the treatment of children, for example. In the medieval period, it was considered quite legitimate to either kill them, or throw them out, or treat them brutally, all sorts of things. It still happens of course, but now it's regarded as pathological, not proper. Well, it's not that we have a different moral capacity than people did in the Middle Ages, it's just that the situation's changed: there are opportunities to think about things that weren't available in a society that had a lower material production level and so on. So we've just learned more about our own moral sense in that area.
I think it's part of moral progress to be able to face things that once looked as if they weren't problems. I have that kind of feeling about our relation to animals, for example--I think the questions there are hard, in fact. A lot of these things are matters of trying to explore your own moral intuitions, and if you've never explored them, you don't know what they are. Abortion's a similar case--there are complicated moral issues. Feminist issues were a similar case. Slavery was a similar case. I mean, some of these things seem easy now, because we've solved them and there's a kind of shared consensus--but I think it's a very good thing that people are asking questions these days about, say, animals rights. I think there are serious questions there. Like, to what extent do we have a right to experiment on and torture animals? I mean, yes, you want to do animal experimentation for the prevention of diseases. But what's the balance, where's the trade-off? There's obviously got to be some. Like, we'd all agree that too much torture of animals for treating a disease would not permissible. But what are the principles on which we draw such conclusions? That's not a trivial question.
MAN: What about eating?
Same question.
MAN: Are you a vegetarian?
I'm not, but I think it's a serious question. If you want my guess, my guess is that if society continues to develop without catastrophe on something like the course you can see over time, I wouldn't in the least be surprised if it moves in the direction of vegetarianism and the protection of animal rights.
Look, doubtless there's plenty of hypocrisy and confusion and everything else about the question right now, but that doesn't mean that the issue isn't valid. And I think one can see the moral force to it--definitely one should keep an open mind on it, it's certainly a perfectly intelligible idea to us.
I mean, you don't have to go back every far in history to find gratuitous torture of animals. So in Cartesian philosophy, they thought they'd proven that humans had minds and everything else in the world was a machine--so there's no difference between a cat and a watch, let's say, just the cat's a little more complicated. And if you look back at the French Court in the seventeenth century, courtiers--you know, big smart guys who'd studied all this stuff and thought they understood it--would as a sport take Lady So-And-So's favorite dog and kick it and beat it to death, and laugh, saying, "Ha, ha, look, this silly lady doesn't understand the latest philosophy, which shows that it's just like dropping a rock on the floor." That was gratuitous torture of animals, and it was regarded as if it were the torturing of a rock; you can't do it, there's no way to torture a rock. Well, the moral sphere has certainly changed in that respect--gratuitous torture of animals is no longer considered quite legitimate.
MAN: But in that case it could be that what's changed is our understanding of what an animal is, not the understanding of our underlying values.
In that case it probably was--because in fact the Cartesian view was a departure from the traditional view, in which you didn't torture animals gratuitously. On the other hand, there are cultures, like say aristocratic cultures, that have fox-hunting as a sport, or bear-baiting, or other things like that, in which gratuitous torture of animals has been seen as perfectly legitimate.
In fact, it's kind of intriguing to see how we regard this. Take cock-fighting, for example, in which cocks are trained to tear each other to shreds. Our culture happens to regard that as barbaric; on the other hand, we train humans to tear each other to shreds--they're called boxing matches--and that's not regarded as barbaric. So there are things that we don't permit of cocks that we permit of poor people. Well, you know, there are some funny values at work there.
MAN: You mentioned abortion--what's your view about that whole debate?
I think it's a hard one, I don't think the answers are simple--it's a case where there really are conflicting values. See, it's very rare in most human situations that there's a clear and simple answer about what's right, and sometimes the answers are very murky, because there are different values, and values do conflict. I mean, our understanding of our own moral value system is that it's not like an axiom system, where there's always one answer and not some other answer. Rather we have what appear to be conflicting values, which often lead us to different answers--maybe because we don't understand all the values well enough yet, or maybe because they really are in conflict. Well, in the case of abortion, there are just straight conflicts. From one point of view, a child up to a certain point is an organ of the mother's body, and the mother ought to have a decision what to do--and that's true. From another point of view, the organism is a potential human being, and it has rights. And those two values are simply in conflict.
On the other hand, a biologist I know once suggested that we may one day be able to see the same conflict when a woman washes her hands. I mean, when a woman washes her hands, a lot of cells flake off--and in principle, each of those cells has the genetic instructions for a human being. Well, you could imagine a future technology which would take one of those cells, and create a human being from it. Now, obviously he was making the argument as a reductio ad absurdum argument, but there's an element of truth to it--not that much yet, but it's not like saying something about astrology. What he's saying is true.
If you want to know my own personal judgment, I would say a reasonable proposal at this point is that the fetus changes from an organ to a person when it becomes viable--but certainly that's arguable. And besides, as this biologist was pointing out, it's not very clear when that is--depending on the state of technology, it could be when the woman's washing her hands. That's life, though: in life you're faced with hard decisions, conflicting values.
Well, there's a sense in which the claim is certainly true. First of all, human nature is something we don't know much about: doubtless there is a rich and complex human nature, and doubtless it's largely genetically determined, like everything else--but we don't know what it is. However, there is enough evidence from history and experience to demonstrate that human nature is entirely consistent with everything you mentioned--in fact, by definition it has to be. So we know that human nature, and that includes our nature, yours and mine, can very easily turn people into quite efficient torturers and mass-murderers and slave-drivers. We know that--you don't have to look very far for evidence. But what does that mean? Should people therefore not try to stop torture? If you see somebody beating a child to death, should you say, "Well, you know, that's human nature"--which it is in fact: there certainly are conditions under which people will act like that.
To the extent that the statement is true, and there is such an extent, it's just not relevant: human nature also has the capacity to lead to selflessness, and cooperation, and sacrifice, and support, and solidarity, and tremendous courage, and lots of other things too.
I mean, my general feeling is that over time, there's measurable progress--it's not huge, but it's significant. And sometimes it's been pretty dramatic. Over history, there's been a real widening of the moral realm, I think--a recognition of broader and broader domains of individuals who are regarded as moral agents, meaning having rights. Look, we are self-conscious beings, we're not rocks, and we can come to get a better understanding of our own nature, it can become more and more realized over time--not because you read a book about it, the book doesn't have anything to tell you, because nobody really knows anything about this topic. But just through experience--including historical experience, which is part of our personal experience because it's embedded in the culture we enter into--we can gain greater understanding of our nature and values.
Take the treatment of children, for example. In the medieval period, it was considered quite legitimate to either kill them, or throw them out, or treat them brutally, all sorts of things. It still happens of course, but now it's regarded as pathological, not proper. Well, it's not that we have a different moral capacity than people did in the Middle Ages, it's just that the situation's changed: there are opportunities to think about things that weren't available in a society that had a lower material production level and so on. So we've just learned more about our own moral sense in that area.
I think it's part of moral progress to be able to face things that once looked as if they weren't problems. I have that kind of feeling about our relation to animals, for example--I think the questions there are hard, in fact. A lot of these things are matters of trying to explore your own moral intuitions, and if you've never explored them, you don't know what they are. Abortion's a similar case--there are complicated moral issues. Feminist issues were a similar case. Slavery was a similar case. I mean, some of these things seem easy now, because we've solved them and there's a kind of shared consensus--but I think it's a very good thing that people are asking questions these days about, say, animals rights. I think there are serious questions there. Like, to what extent do we have a right to experiment on and torture animals? I mean, yes, you want to do animal experimentation for the prevention of diseases. But what's the balance, where's the trade-off? There's obviously got to be some. Like, we'd all agree that too much torture of animals for treating a disease would not permissible. But what are the principles on which we draw such conclusions? That's not a trivial question.
MAN: What about eating?
Same question.
MAN: Are you a vegetarian?
I'm not, but I think it's a serious question. If you want my guess, my guess is that if society continues to develop without catastrophe on something like the course you can see over time, I wouldn't in the least be surprised if it moves in the direction of vegetarianism and the protection of animal rights.
Look, doubtless there's plenty of hypocrisy and confusion and everything else about the question right now, but that doesn't mean that the issue isn't valid. And I think one can see the moral force to it--definitely one should keep an open mind on it, it's certainly a perfectly intelligible idea to us.
I mean, you don't have to go back every far in history to find gratuitous torture of animals. So in Cartesian philosophy, they thought they'd proven that humans had minds and everything else in the world was a machine--so there's no difference between a cat and a watch, let's say, just the cat's a little more complicated. And if you look back at the French Court in the seventeenth century, courtiers--you know, big smart guys who'd studied all this stuff and thought they understood it--would as a sport take Lady So-And-So's favorite dog and kick it and beat it to death, and laugh, saying, "Ha, ha, look, this silly lady doesn't understand the latest philosophy, which shows that it's just like dropping a rock on the floor." That was gratuitous torture of animals, and it was regarded as if it were the torturing of a rock; you can't do it, there's no way to torture a rock. Well, the moral sphere has certainly changed in that respect--gratuitous torture of animals is no longer considered quite legitimate.
MAN: But in that case it could be that what's changed is our understanding of what an animal is, not the understanding of our underlying values.
In that case it probably was--because in fact the Cartesian view was a departure from the traditional view, in which you didn't torture animals gratuitously. On the other hand, there are cultures, like say aristocratic cultures, that have fox-hunting as a sport, or bear-baiting, or other things like that, in which gratuitous torture of animals has been seen as perfectly legitimate.
In fact, it's kind of intriguing to see how we regard this. Take cock-fighting, for example, in which cocks are trained to tear each other to shreds. Our culture happens to regard that as barbaric; on the other hand, we train humans to tear each other to shreds--they're called boxing matches--and that's not regarded as barbaric. So there are things that we don't permit of cocks that we permit of poor people. Well, you know, there are some funny values at work there.
MAN: You mentioned abortion--what's your view about that whole debate?
I think it's a hard one, I don't think the answers are simple--it's a case where there really are conflicting values. See, it's very rare in most human situations that there's a clear and simple answer about what's right, and sometimes the answers are very murky, because there are different values, and values do conflict. I mean, our understanding of our own moral value system is that it's not like an axiom system, where there's always one answer and not some other answer. Rather we have what appear to be conflicting values, which often lead us to different answers--maybe because we don't understand all the values well enough yet, or maybe because they really are in conflict. Well, in the case of abortion, there are just straight conflicts. From one point of view, a child up to a certain point is an organ of the mother's body, and the mother ought to have a decision what to do--and that's true. From another point of view, the organism is a potential human being, and it has rights. And those two values are simply in conflict.
On the other hand, a biologist I know once suggested that we may one day be able to see the same conflict when a woman washes her hands. I mean, when a woman washes her hands, a lot of cells flake off--and in principle, each of those cells has the genetic instructions for a human being. Well, you could imagine a future technology which would take one of those cells, and create a human being from it. Now, obviously he was making the argument as a reductio ad absurdum argument, but there's an element of truth to it--not that much yet, but it's not like saying something about astrology. What he's saying is true.
If you want to know my own personal judgment, I would say a reasonable proposal at this point is that the fetus changes from an organ to a person when it becomes viable--but certainly that's arguable. And besides, as this biologist was pointing out, it's not very clear when that is--depending on the state of technology, it could be when the woman's washing her hands. That's life, though: in life you're faced with hard decisions, conflicting values.
Tags:
chomsky,
news and politics
Saturday Youtube Post
Leaving tomorrow morning for Michigan and I likely won't have internet access for a week, here's the youtubez
CASSINI MISSION from Chris Abbas on Vimeo.
Tags:
science and technology,
youtube
Friday, August 5, 2011
Malcolm X at the Oxford Union, 1967
One of my favorite speeches. He'd be assassinated two months later.
Tags:
history,
news and politics
Tuesday, August 2, 2011
Keith's reaction to the debt ceiling deal - Get mad.
Huh. Someone on television telling people what they need to hear. Small wonder MSNBC fired him.
Is it bad that my eyes rolled instinctively when he said "We must rise, nonviolently"? I think people should start smashing shit in the streets, personally. How many more times are we going to let the upper 1% do this to us? Are we ever going to draw a line, or are we just going let them keep at that successful tactic of chipping away, little by little?
But Keith is also on television, so I guess he can't just go and incite riots if he doesn't want to get thrown in jail. I came across an essay the other day called Pacifism as Pathology, which I'm pretty sure was written by an anarchist. The guy strongly criticizes the pacifist peace movement as entirely useless, claims it's never accomplished a thing, and dismisses it as pseudospiritual nonsense, almost like a cult. Considering that this is the tactic liberals have been using since the 60s, and considering that what it's accomplished is where we're at now, I find myself agreeing with this assessment more than I'm disagreeing with it. If I wind up dead under mysterious circumstances, I didn't commit suicide.
The betrayal of what this nation was supposed to be about did not begin with this deal and it surely will not end with this deal. There is a tide pushing back the rights of each of us, and it has been artificially induced by union bashing, and the sowing of hatreds and fears, and now this evermore institutionalized economic battering of the average American. It will continue and it will crush us, because those that created it are organized, and unified, and hell-bent. And the only response is to be organized, and unified and hell-bent in return.
Is it bad that my eyes rolled instinctively when he said "We must rise, nonviolently"? I think people should start smashing shit in the streets, personally. How many more times are we going to let the upper 1% do this to us? Are we ever going to draw a line, or are we just going let them keep at that successful tactic of chipping away, little by little?
But Keith is also on television, so I guess he can't just go and incite riots if he doesn't want to get thrown in jail. I came across an essay the other day called Pacifism as Pathology, which I'm pretty sure was written by an anarchist. The guy strongly criticizes the pacifist peace movement as entirely useless, claims it's never accomplished a thing, and dismisses it as pseudospiritual nonsense, almost like a cult. Considering that this is the tactic liberals have been using since the 60s, and considering that what it's accomplished is where we're at now, I find myself agreeing with this assessment more than I'm disagreeing with it. If I wind up dead under mysterious circumstances, I didn't commit suicide.
Pacifism, the ideology of nonviolent political action, has become axiomatic and all but universal among the more progressive elements of contemporary mainstream North America. With a jargon ranging from a peculiar mishmash of borrowed or fabricated pseudospiritualism to “Gramscian” notions of prefigurative socialization, pacifism appears as the common denominator linking otherwise disparate “white dissident” groupings. Always, it promises that the harsh realities of state power can be transcended via good feelings and purity of purpose rather than by self-defense and resort to combat.
Pacifists, with seemingly endless repetition, pronounce that the negativity of the modern corporate-fascist state will atrophy through defection and neglect once there is a sufficiently positive social vision to take its place (“What if they gave a war and nobody came?”). Known in the Middle Ages as alchemy, such insistence on the repetition of insubstantial themes and failed experiments to obtain a desired result has long been consigned to the realm of fantasy, discarded by all but the most wishful or cynical (who use it to manipulate people).
Tags:
news and politics
Monday, August 1, 2011
Reconstructionist South
After the Civil War, now that blacks had the right to vote, there was a brief surge in black politicians in the south. In 1868, in a shocking display of racist authoritarianism, the Georgia legislature voted to expel all of its black members -- 2 senators, and 25 representatives. Henry MacNeal Turner, a black Georgia representative who had escaped slavery at the age of fifteen, gave this speech to the Georgia House. This was only rediscovered by a black woman graduate student at Atlanta university many decades later.
--
Mr. Speaker. . . . I wish the members of this House to understand the position that I take. I hold that I am a member of this body. Therefore, sir, I shall neither fawn or cringe before any party, nor stoop to beg them for my rights. . . . I am here to demand my rights, and to hurl thunderbolts at the men who would dare to cross the threshold of my manhood. . . .
The scene presented in this House, today, is one unparalleled in the history of the world. . . . Never, in the history of the world, has a man been arraigned before a body clothed with legislative, judicial or executive functions, charged with the offense of being of a darker hue than his fellow men. . . . it has remained for the State of Georgia, in the very heart of the nineteenth century, to call a man before the bar, and there charge him with an act for which he is no more responsible than for the head which he carries upon his shoulders. The Anglo-Saxon race, sir, is a most surprising one. . . . I was not aware that there was in the character of that race so much cowardice, or so much pusillanimity. . . . I tell you, sir, that this is a question which will not die today. This event shall be remembered by posterity for ages yet to come, and while the sun shall continue to climb the hills of heaven. . . .
We are told that if black men want to speak, they must speak through white trumpets; if black men want their sentiments expressed, they must be adulterated and sent through white messengers, who will quibble, and equivocate, and evade, as rapidly as the pendulum of a clock. . . .
The great question, sir is this: Am I a man? If I am such, I claim the rights of a man. . . .
Why, sir, though we are not white, we have accomplished much. We have pioneered civilization here; we have built up your country; we have worked in your fields, and garnered your harvests, for two hundred and fifty years! And what do we ask of you in return? Do we ask you for compensation for the sweat our fathers bore for you--for the tears you have caused, and the hearts you have broken, and the lives you have curtailed, and the blood you have spilled? Do we ask for retaliation? We ask it not. We are willing to let the dead past bury its dead; but we ask you now for our RIGHTS. . . .
Tags:
history,
news and politics
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
